aclea
Lead HumanelyJuly 13, 20267 min readBy Mark Bregenzer

You cannot not lead

Why everything you do is read as leadership - including your silence.

Three glasses in different colors project dashed lines into an empty speech bubble

It is Monday morning, team meeting. The numbers have collapsed; everyone in the room expects a thunderstorm. The leader says: nothing. She nods, takes notes, works through the agenda as planned. By the afternoon, three readings of this silence are circulating in the team: The boss is disappointed. She has given up. She does not know what to do herself. None of these readings was sent. All three were received.

More than fifty years ago, Paul Watzlawick formulated an axiom that became a classic: one cannot not communicate. As soon as people perceive each other, everything carries a message, including the unsaid: the email that goes unanswered, the proposal that is passed over without comment, the glance at the watch. Whoever is visible is sending, whether they want to or not.

Is it not tempting to take the sentence one turn further? If one cannot not communicate, and if leadership is at its core communication, then one cannot not lead either.

The flaw in the logic

We like this way of seeing things. But we want to be honest: as a logical conclusion, it does not hold. Watzlawick's axiom strictly delivers only that we always communicate. That we always lead would follow only if leadership and communication were the same thing. They are not: all leadership happens through communication, but not all communication is leadership. Small talk at the coffee machine leads no one.

The sentence becomes interesting when you change the direction of view: away from the sender, towards the receiver. The psychology of communication made this shift long ago. Friedemann Schulz von Thun, known for his four-sides model, puts it succinctly: the message that arrives is a construction of the receiver. What a message means is not decided by whoever sends it.

In an existing leadership relationship, and that is the decisive frame, every behavior of the leading person is read through a particular pair of glasses. What she addresses counts as important. What she ignores counts as unimportant. Her hesitation becomes insecurity, her absence becomes a signal, her silence becomes a message with three readings. It is not that the leader always leads. But her environment always reads leadership.

Three pieces of evidence

This is not a mere observation from consulting practice. Research supports this view from several sides.

First: culture is embedded, not proclaimed. The organizational psychologist Edgar Schein described the mechanisms through which leaders shape culture: what they pay attention to, what they measure, how they react to critical incidents, what they model. The crucial thing about this list: it works consciously as well as unconsciously. The cultural message is sent even when no one meant to send it. In consulting practice, the same finding has become known as the "Shadow of the Leader": over time, organizations come to resemble the behavior of their leadership, not its pronouncements.

Second: when it comes to leadership, the receiver reads especially thoroughly. What Schulz von Thun describes for messages in general applies to leadership in intensified form. In the eighties, James Meindl and colleagues described an effect they called the "Romance of Leadership": observers attribute outcomes, good and bad alike, disproportionately to leadership. Leadership thus exists not only in the actions of the leading person, but essentially in the perception of the led. The receiver's construction has a favorite ingredient here: the leader.

Third, and most vividly: silence is read, immediately. A Swedish video study observed trauma teams during training. When team leaders hesitated or stayed silent, ambiguity arose, and other team members began to take over the leader's tasks. The not-leading was not overlooked. It was read and answered, within seconds.

What this means when anyone can lead

In the classical hierarchy, the leadership glasses sit firmly: one person is read through them, everyone else is read as colleagues. Collaborative leadership changes that fundamentally. Where leadership is an activity and not a position, the glasses attach themselves to the moment: whoever proposes the direction in the review, whoever speaks up in the crisis, is read as leadership exactly then, with everything that comes with it - the hesitation acquires interpretive weight, the tone becomes a signal. This, by the way, explains a phenomenon many know from teams: the reluctance to seize a moment of leadership. Behind it lies not only fear of responsibility, but the entirely correct intuition of being read differently from that moment on.

The sharpest turn, however, concerns the team itself. Where each and every one could lead, the not-leading of all sends as well: when the obvious problem remains unnamed in the meeting and no one seizes the moment, everyone in the room reads the same message - this is not something we address here. The reading of Watzlawick's axiom also holds in the plural: a team, too, cannot not lead.

With that, one of the most-quoted resolutions of the leadership literature turns around as well. "Leading by example" is often presented as a decision, as something one resolves to do. The receiver's logic says: you are setting an example anyway, every day, in every gesture, even in silence - and in a collaborative organization this holds not only for the top, but for everyone. What you cannot choose is whether you are a role model. What you can choose is which one.

This is exactly where it becomes clear why Authenticity & Integrity is the first principle of collaborative leadership - the beginning of the aclea development journey. If potentially everyone is read, authenticity can no longer be a boss's virtue; it must become a capability of the whole crew. And integrity, meaning values that live in action and not in the mission statement, is the condition under which people can follow changing leadership at all: I only engage with a rotating moment of leadership if what I see corresponds to what is there. Authenticity therefore does not stand at the beginning as a moral overture, but as a condition of entry. Distributed leadership without it produces not distributed strength, but distributed noise.

The receiver's side of leadership is one of the building blocks of our book "Angewandte Kollaborative Führung" (Applied Collaborative Leadership), which is currently in the making. If you do not want to miss the publication:

Subscribe to the newsletter
SOURCES
  • Watzlawick, P., Beavin, J. H. & Jackson, D. D. (1967): Pragmatics of Human Communication. A Study of Interactional Patterns, Pathologies, and Paradoxes. Norton.
  • Schulz von Thun, F. (1981): Miteinander reden 1: Störungen und Klärungen. Rowohlt.
  • Schein, E. H. (1985): Organizational Culture and Leadership. Jossey-Bass.
  • Meindl, J. R., Ehrlich, S. B. & Dukerich, J. M. (1985): The Romance of Leadership. Administrative Science Quarterly 30(1), 78-102.
  • Härgestam, M., Hultin, M., Brulin, C. & Jacobsson, M. (2016): Trauma team leaders' non-verbal communication. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine 24(37).